Commonwealth v. Coffey

In 1994, Jerome Coffey was tried for his alleged participation in an attempted robbery which resulted in a shooting death. He was convicted of felony murder solely based on his participation in the robbery and was sentenced to mandatory life without parole. Earlier this year, however, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a groundbreaking decision in the case of Commonwealth v. Lee, which found that mandatory life without parole for felony murder violated the Pennsylvania Constitution’s prohibition of “cruel” punishment. The Court refused to rule on the retroactivity of the constitutional mandate and instead gave the Pennsylvania legislature 120 days to adopt an appropriate remedy for the roughly 1,100 people who are currently serving mandatory life sentences for felony murder convictions in the Commonwealth. The legislature failed to act and the Supreme Court took up Mr. Coffey’s post-conviction appeal to address whether Lee will be applied retroactively.

Juvenile Law Center, along with Youth Sentencing and Reentry Project, filed an amicus brief in support of the retroactive application of Lee’s ban on life without parole for those convicted of felony murder who did not kill or intend to kill. Our brief argued that the successful resentencing, release, and reintegration of hundreds of Pennsylvanians following Miller v. Alabama and Montgomery v. Louisiana proves that applying Lee retroactively is both practical and critical. We argued that retroactive relief is particularly important for the hundreds of young adults twenty-five and younger sentenced to die in prison whose developmental stage reduces their culpability. We also argued that unconstitutional life without parole sentences have disproportionately harmed Black young adults, who are significantly overrepresented in the population confined for felony murder. Finally, we shared the stories of individuals previously sentenced to die in prison who have since come home and have been making a meaningful impact in their communities and families.

LEGAL TEAM

Attorneys

Lia Knox-Hershey, Andrew Keats, Jessica Feierman

Paralegals

Spencer Symula, Tiffany Faith